Type 21 frigate


HMS Amazon during Exercise RIMPAC 86
Class overview
Name: Type 21 Amazon
Builders: Yarrow Shipbuilders,
Vosper Thornycroft
Operators:  Royal Navy
 Pakistan Navy
Preceded by: Type 12M Leander
Succeeded by: Type 22 Broadsword
Subclasses: Niteroi class frigate
In commission: 11 May 1974
Completed: 8
Active: 6
Lost: 2
General characteristics
Type: Frigate
Displacement: As built;
  • 2,750 tons (standard)
  • 3,250 tons (full load)
After strengthening;
  • 2,860 tons (standard)
  • 3,360 tons (full load)
Length: 360 ft (109.7 m (w/l))
384 ft (117 m (o/a))
Beam: 41.8 ft (12.7 m)
Draught: 19 ft (6.8 m)
Propulsion: COGOG on 2 shafts;
  • 2 Tyne cruise turbines; 8,500 shp (6 MW)
  • 2 Olympus boost turbines; 50,000 shp (37 MW)
Speed: 32 kt (Olympus) / 18 kt (Tyne)
Range:

4,000 nmi at 17 kt
3,500 nmi at 18 kt

1,200 nmi at 30 kt
Complement: 13 officers, 164 ratings
Sensors and
processing systems:

1 x Radar Type 992Q low-level search
1 x Radar Type 978 navigation
2 x Radar Type 912 fire-control

Sonar Type 184M and 162M
Armament: later additions;
  • 4 x launchers for MM38 Exocet surface-surface missiles
  • 2 x 12.75" (324mm) 3-tube STWS-1 anti-submarine torpedo launchers
Aircraft carried: 1 x Wasp or Lynx
Aviation facilities: Flight deck and hangar

The Type 21 frigate or Amazon-class frigate was a Royal Navy general-purpose escort designed in the late 1960s, built in the 1970s and that served throughout the 1980s into the 1990s.

Contents

History

The class was designed to fulfill a requirement for a relatively cheap yet modern general purpose escort vessel to fill a projected gap in the number of escort hulls in the fleet. Many older vessels were rapidly approaching the end of their useful lives yet their replacements, the Type 42 destroyer and Type 22 frigate, would not be ready until the mid-to-late 1970s. The Admiralty design board were busy with the latter, therefore the Type 21 project was given to private shipyards Vosper Thornycroft and Yarrow. The unmistakably yacht-like and rakish lines were indicative of their commercial design. Their handsome looks combined with their impressive handling and acceleration lent itself to the class nickname of Porsches.

The design was partially funded by the Royal Australian Navy who were planning a Light Destroyer (DDL) class of ten ships to be built at the Cockatoo Island Dockyard in Sydney. This original number was revised down to five and then three vessels. With the election of the Whitlam Labor Government in 1972 the whole DDL program was cancelled and Australian involvement ceased.

The first of the eight built, HMS Amazon, entered service in May 1974.

Design

These ships were the Royal Navy's first privately designed modern frigates. They were also the first design to enter service which used solely gas-turbine propulsion, as opposed to the steam turbines or diesel engines of their predecessors. The design made use of large amounts of aluminium alloy in the superstructure to lower the amount of topweight but worries later surfaced about its resilience to fire, particularly following a major fire on Amazon in 1977 during which aluminium ladders distorted, preventing fire-fighting teams from reaching the blaze. Later warships reverted to using steel again.

As originally built, the Type 21 design made use of a lot of "off the shelf" technology, such as the old Sea Cat missile (combined with the Italian-built Alenia Orion-10X fire-control system - as the GWS-24 system), the Wasp anti-submarine helicopter, and marinized Rolls-Royce aircraft engines. Yet it also featured modern electronics such as the CAAIS (Computer Assisted Action Information System) system to integrate the ship's weapons and sensor systems and provide the crew with all the relevant information they required to fight the ship, as and when they needed it.

In terms of automation, systems integration and habitability they were well in advance of many of their older Royal Navy contemporaries, such as the Type 81 frigate and Rothesay-class frigate, the latter of whose basic design could be traced back to 1945.

Modifications

When they entered service, the Type 21s were immediately criticized for being woefully under-armed. A program was put in hand to increase their fire power by fitting 4 French-built MM38 Exocet anti-ship missiles. These were sited in front of the bridge screen aft of the forecastle, displacing the Corvus countermeasure launchers to amidships. This improvement was carried out to all ships of the class except Antelope and Ambuscade, the latter was fitted with Exocet in 1984/5. The Exocets were located in two pairs and the missiles would deploy across the ship and clear the opposite side of the vessel to their launchers in flight. This differed from the later type 22 frigates where deployment of the missiles was to the same side of the vessel as the missile pairs were fitted. The Westland Wasp, a single-role torpedo-carrying helicopter, was replaced by the vastly more capable multi-mission Westland Lynx when it became available. Ship-launched anti-submarine torpedoes were also fitted as and when ships came in for refit, in the form of two STWS-1 triple-tube launchers capable of firing United States USN/NATO-standard Mark 44 or Mark 46 torpedoes. After the Falklands War two more 20mm Oerlikon guns were mounted each side of the hangar to provide extra close-in armament on some ships of the class.

Analysis

Criticism was levelled at the performance of the type in the Falklands conflict. The ships developed cracks in their decks due to the differing expansion properties of steel and aluminium. This was a vulnerability particularly demonstrated under the severe weather conditions they encountered in the South Atlantic. Steel reinforcing plates were eventually fitted down the sides of the ships. Built to an exacting budget and design specification (and although carrying obsolete anti-aircraft weaponry), they distinguished themselves in a theatre for which they were not designed.

The class was also criticised for being overcrowded; however, at 384 ft (117 m) they had 177 crewmen compared to 436 ft (133 m) and just 185 crewmen for the modern Type 23 frigate. This was important at a time when the Royal Navy was facing a manpower shortage. The standard of accommodation for the officers was better than the RN average and the senior ratings enjoyed separate cabins – unlike the petty officers of the Type 42 destroyer of the same era, who slept in bunk rooms. The ratings' accommodation was also improved, with four-man sleeping berths leading off from the communal mess deck. The accommodation arrangements (designed by a woman) were far better than those of the Type 42 destroyer. With little capability to modernise (owing to its small size) and already being close to its topweight limit, the Type 21's days were numbered. Nevertheless, these ships were regarded favorably with their crews and proved to be useful assets in a navy severely depleted in the number of modern escort hulls.

Active service

All of the class except Amazon, as the 4th Frigate Squadron, took part in the Falklands War of 1982. They were heavily involved, performing extensive shore-bombardment missions and providing anti-submarine and anti-aircraft duties for the task force. Two vessels were lost, Ardent was hit by bombs dropped by Argentine aircraft on May 21 and was consumed by fire. HMS Antelope was hit by bombs on May 23, one of which was set off by the bomb disposal team attempting to defuse it on May 24, causing the ship to break her back and sink. It is highly unlikely that any ship of this size would be able to survive a direct hit from aerial bombs, and that they stayed afloat as long as they did to allow the evacuation of their crews is testament to the design.

Disposal

All six of the surviving Type 21 frigates were sold to Pakistan in 1993–1994. The class was renamed by the Pakistani Navy as the Tariq class, after the first vessel that was acquired, the PNS Tariq, formerly HMS Ambuscade. All six ships remain in service, as of 2011. They have had their Sea Cat launcher removed, as well as their Exocet missiles. Three of the ships had their Exocet missiles replaced by the more capable US-made Harpoon missile, the other three were fitted with the Chinese 6-cell LY-60N Hunting Eagle surface-to-air missile system.[1]

Ships

"A contract was awarded to Vosper Thornycroft on 27 February 1968 for the design of a patrol frigate to be prepared in full collaboration with Yarrow Ltd."[2] They were "designed to replace the Leopard- and Salisbury-class frigates. Initial cost were to be £3.5 million but HMS Amazon actually cost" £16.8 million.[3]

Pennant Name (a) Hull builder Ordered Laid down Launched Accepted into service[4] Commissioned Est. building cost[5] Fate
F169 Amazon Vosper Thornycroft, Woolston 26 March 1969 [6] 6 November 1969 [6] 26 April 1971 [6] 19 July 1974 [7] 11 May 1974 [6] £16.8M [7] To Pakistan as Babur
F170 Antelope Vosper Thornycroft 11 May 1970 [6] 23 March 1971 [6] 16 March 1972 [6] 30 June 1975 [7] 16 July 1975 [6] £14.4M [8] Bombed by Argentine A-4 Skyhawks 23 May 1982 and sank following day in San Carlos Water
F172 Ambuscade Yarrow Shipbuilders, Scotstoun 11 November 1971 [6] 1 September 1971 [6] 18 January 1973 [6] 23 August 1975 [7] 5 September 1975 [6] £16.5M [7] To Pakistan as Tariq
F173 Arrow YSL 11 November 1971 [6] 28 September 1972 [6] 5 February 1974 [6] 16 May 1975 [7] 29 July 1976 [6] £20.2M [7] To Pakistan as Khaibar
F171 Active Vosper Thornycroft 11 May 1970 [6] 21 July 1971 [6] 23 November 1972 [6] 2 June 1977 [7] 17 June 1977 [6] £24.1M [7] To Pakistan as Shah Jahan
F174 Alacrity YSL 11 November 1971 [6] 5 March 1973 [6] 18 September 1974 [6] 2 April 1977 [7] 2 July 1977 [6] £23.8M [7] To Pakistan as Badr
F184 Ardent YSL 11 November 1971 [6] 26 February 1974 [6] 9 May 1975 [6] 10 September 1977 [7] 14 October 1977 [6] £26.3M [7] Bombed by Argentine A-4 Skyhawks 21 May 1982 in San Carlos Water and sank following day in Grantham Sound
F185 Avenger YSL 11 November 1971 [6] 30 October 1974 [6] 20 November 1975 [6] 15 April 1978 [7] 15 April 1978 [6] £27.7M [9] To Pakistan as Tippu Sultan

Running costs

Date Running cost What is included Citation
1981-82 £6.5 million Average annual running cost of Type 21s at average 1981–82 prices and including associated aircraft costs but excluding the costs of major refits. [10]
1985-86 £7 million The average cost of running and maintaining a type 21 frigate for one year. [11]
1987-88 £3.8 million The average annual operating costs, at financial year 1987-88 prices of a type 21 frigate. These costs include personnel, fuel, spares and so on, and administrative support services, but exclude new construction, capital equipment, and refit-repair costs. [12]

See also

Media related to [//commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Type_21_frigates Type 21 frigates] at Wikimedia Commons

Footnotes

  1. ^ http://www.defensenews.com/story.php?i=4275032
  2. ^ Moore, John Jane's Fighting Ships, 1982-83, pub Jane's Publishing Co Ltd, 1982, ISBN 0-7106-0742-3 page 554.
  3. ^ HMS Ambuscade Facts and Figures, which contains a common internet site error and quotes the cost of Antelope as the cost of Amazon. More accurate figures for costs of Type 21 frigates are in: Hansard: HC Deb 23 October 1989 vol 158 cc357-8W 357W Question to the Secretary of State for Defence regarding warship costs, 23 October 1989.
  4. ^ The term used in Navy Estimates and Defence Estimates is "accepted into service". Hansard has used the term acceptance date. Leo Marriott in his various books uses the term "completed", as does Jane's Fighting Ships. These terms all mean the same thing: the date the Navy accepts the vessel from the builder. This date is important because maintenance cycles, etc. are generally calculated from the acceptance date.
  5. ^ "Unit cost, i.e. excluding cost of certain items (e.g. aircraft, First Outfits)." - Text from Defences Estimates
    "They do not include other costs, such as those for Government Furnished Equipment (GFE)—as they are not held centrally for each ship and could be provided only at disproportionate cost." Bob Ainsworth, Minister of State for the Armed Forces, 16 July 2008.
  6. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z aa ab ac ad ae af Lippiett, John Modern Combat Ships 5, Type 21, pub Ian Allan, 1990, ISBN 0-7110-1903-7 page 16.
  7. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n Hansard: HC Deb 23 October 1989 vol 158 cc357-8W 357W Question to the Secretary of State for Defence regarding warship costs, 23 October 1989. This section is mislabelled - it is the first part of the table that is continued on Hansard: HC Deb 23 October 1989 vol 158 c360W .
  8. ^
    Hansard HC Deb 27 May 1982 vol 24 c397W Question to the Secretary of State for Defence as to the current replacement cost of an Antelope class of frigate, 27 May 1982.
    Hansard: HC Deb 23 October 1989 vol 158 cc357-8W 357W Question to the Secretary of State for Defence regarding warship costs, 23 October 1989.
    Moore, John Jane's Fighting Ships, 1982-83, pub Jane's Publishing Co Ltd, 1982, ISBN 0-7106-0742-3 page 554.
  9. ^ Hansard: HC Deb 23 October 1989 vol 158 cc357-8W 357W Question to the Secretary of State for Defence regarding warship costs, 23 October 1989 says £27.7 million.
    Moore, John Jane's Fighting Ships, 1982-83, pub Jane's Publishing Co Ltd, 1982, ISBN 0-7106-0742-3 page 554 says £28.3 million.
  10. ^ Hansard HC Deb 16 July 1982 vol 27 cc485-6W Question to the Secretary of State for Defence about operating costs of naval vessels, 16 July 1982.
  11. ^ Hansard HC Deb 22 January 1987 vol 108 c730W Question to the Secretary of State for Defence about operating costs of naval vessels, 22 January 1987.
  12. ^ Hansard HC Deb 10 March 1989 vol 148 c44W Question to the Secretary of State for Defence about operating costs of naval vessels, 10 March 1989.

References